Red Flags to Watch Out for When Choosing Indy's Finest Fence Installer
Choosing the wrong fence contractor can lead to expensive mistakes that impact your home’s security, aesthetics, and long-term expenses. For instance, poor workmanship can result in unstable, sagging, or misaligned fences, requiring frequent repairs. Additionally, hidden fees, project delays, and lack of warranties can further increase costs and frustration. To avoid these and many other costly pitfalls, hiring Indy’s finest fence installer should be non-negotiable.
That said, there are common red flags you must avoid if you really want to find the best contractor. Superior Fence & Rail of Indianapolis has addressed five key warning signs to watch out for. Take a look!
1. Lack of Proper Licensing and Insurance
A good fence company Indianapolis should be appropriately licensed and insured. Licensing typically means that the contractor has:
- Undergone proper training and understands industry standards
- Complied with Indy’s building codes and regulations
- The knowledge to secure necessary permits and avoid legal issues
A licensed and insured contractor is accountable for their work. Hiring such a contractor reduces the risk of poor workmanship and code violations. An uninsured contractor might offer a lower price, but the risks far outweigh the savings.
Here’s how to protect yourself:
- Ask for proof of licensing before signing any contract
- Verify credentials through local licensing boards or online databases
- Make sure the contractor is appropriately insured. Ensure they have general liability insurance, workers’ compensation coverage, and other necessary insurance coverage or comprehensive insurance.
Investing in a licensed and insured fence installer provides peace of mind. It ensures high-quality work and protects you from costly legal and financial consequences.
2. No Portfolio or Poor Online Presence
An Indy’s finest fence installer should have a portfolio showcasing previous projects. The portfolio ought to demonstrate their expertise, craftsmanship, and consistency. Be cautious if a company:
- Has no website or online presence. Legitimate businesses typically have a website with service details and contact information.
- Uses only stock photos. It could mean they don’t have actual past projects to showcase.
- Has missing or primarily negative reviews. A lack of reviews can indicate a new or untested business. Consistent negative reviews signal a history of bad service.
A well-established fencing company will have a strong online presence. To ensure you’re hiring a trustworthy contractor, check Google Reviews. Here, you’ll find genuine, detailed feedback from past clients. Many contractors share real project photos and interact with customers on social platforms like Facebook. So, check there too.
Asking for references from the installer is also helpful. The installer should be happy to give you contact details of past clients who can vouch for their work.
3. Unrealistically Low Quotes
“Too good to be true” pricing is another major red flag. If a fence company offers an unrealistically lower quote than competitors, that is terrible news! Lowball pricing may indicate:
- The contractor uses subpar materials that won’t last, leading to costly repairs and replacements
- Inexperienced or unlicensed labor, resulting in poor-quality installation
- Lack of warranties, meaning you’ll pay out of pocket if an issue arises
- Bait-and-switch tactics, where the price increases as soon as the work begins
A well-built fence is an investment. Quality contractors charge fair, transparent pricing that reflects proper materials and labor costs. To avoid surprises, always request an estimate that outlines all costs upfront, especially for materials and labor. Superior Fence & Rail of Indianapolis offers a free online fence cost estimator.
However, filling in the Request an Estimate form for the most accurate quote is best. The team at Superior will visit and assess your property in person to give a detailed breakdown of the total price.
4. No Warranty
When investing in a new fence, you expect it to last for years. However, a fence company that doesn’t offer a warranty could signal a lack of confidence in their work. Before hiring a fence company Indianapolis, ask about their warranty and make sure it includes the following:
- Length of coverage. Reputable contractors offer at least 1-5 years.
- What’s covered? Ensure the warranty clearly states the items covered (e.g., workmanship and materials). Superior Fence & Rail offers 3 years of workmanship and a lifetime guarantee on vinyl and aluminum materials.
- Exclusions and conditions. Read the fine print to understand what’s not covered (e.g., storm damage, improper maintenance).
The best fence installation company near me should be confident enough in their materials and craftsmanship to back them up with a warranty. If a company refuses to provide one, it’s a major red flag that you must avoid.
5. Pushy Sales Tactics or High-Pressure Deals
A trustworthy fence contractor should provide clear information and reasonable pricing. Most importantly, the company should give you time to make an informed decision.
However, some contractors use high-pressure sales tactics to rush homeowners into signing a contract without fully understanding the terms. These tactics usually result in overpaying, unnecessary upgrades, or hiring the wrong company.
Indy’s finest fence company should do the following:
- Allow you to compare quotes. A reputable installer understands customers want to research and compare materials, prices, and warranties.
- Answer all your questions. Instead of pressuring you, a reputable company will educate you on materials, installation, and pricing. That instills confidence in your choice.
- Respect your budget. The company doesn’t force unnecessary upgrades just to increase the final cost.
If you feel like you’re being pushed into a deal, stop! That might be a sign that the contractor cares more about profit than quality service. Always choose a company that respects your decision-making process and prioritizes your needs.
Avoid These Common Pitfalls and Hire Indy’s Finest Fence Contractor
Hiring the right fence company guarantees durable materials and quality work. Avoid common pitfalls that could lead to hidden fees, poor installation, and lack of warranties.
Choose a trusted, licensed professional who provides transparent pricing, solid warranties, and excellent customer service. Hire Superior Fence & Rail of Indianapolis and enjoy peace of mind!

Get A Fence Quote Today!
Great Fences Make Great Neighbors!
- Best Quality Fences
- Highest Customer Satisfaction Rating
- Fence Financing Options
- Licensed, Bonded & Insured
Your Superior Fence and Rail service team is standing by! Get a fence installation quote today!